“The Walking Dead” is undoubtedly one of the most popular and successful shows on TV to date. The show offers thrill and suspense, and some episodes can even leave viewers in tears.

But for “The Walking Dead” Season 6 finale, fans were on the edge of their seats as the last episode ended with a major cliffhanger, leaving them to piece things together about who was Lucille’d by Negan.

WARNING: The following content contains spoilers for “The Walking Dead” Season 6 finale

In the last moments of “The Walking Dead” Season 6 finale, Rick and his group are captured by Negan and the Saviors. Fans were left with a chilling monologue from Jeffrey Dean Morgan’s Negan and the most dangerous game of “eenie meenie miney moe.”

Which member of Rick’s group did Negan bludgeon to death? Was it Glenn or Daryl? Could it possibly be Michonne or Carl? Unfortunately, “The Walking Dead” fans will need to wait until October when Season 7 finally premieres.

Until then, all fans can do is to speculate about who was that unlucky person Negan killed in the TWD season 6 finale. Movie Web reports that many have been trying their best to know the identity of the person that Negan Lucille’d without an inch of mercy, but they couldn’t come up with a clear answer.

But the “Last Day on Earth” episode of “The Walking Dead” Season 6 wasn’t like “Thank You” where Glenn was seen being allegedly eaten by the walkers.

It was easier for fans to realize Glenn’s fate when actor Steven Yeun was spotted on the set of “The Walking Dead,” confirming that he survived that episode. This time though is a lot trickier, according to Yahoo. Nobody knew who died, so fans didn’t have a basis who to stalk to know about their character’s fate on the hit show.

It seems like “The Walking Dead” fans are left with no choice but to wait for October to know who was Lucille’d by Negan.